Sarah May
REALTOR®
Contact Agent
My name is Sarah May, and I’m proud to call Neenah home. With a passion for real estate and a commitment to exceptional service, I’m here to help guide you through the process of buying or selling a home with confidence and care.
I’m a proud graduate of the University of Wisconsin–Madison—Go Badgers! My background in public relations, customer service, and account management provides me with strong communication, negotiation, and problem-solving skills that translate seamlessly into real estate. I’m also a real estate investor, which gives me a unique perspective on property value, market trends, and long-term investment potential.
Family is at the heart of everything I do. My husband Jesse and I met in 9th grade in Fond du Lac (back when Goodrich was the high school). Today, we’re raising our two boys, Isaac and Lucas, along with our two energetic boxer dogs, Zelda and Ozlo. My family keeps life fun, busy, and full of laughter.
I’ve always had a knack for decorating and organizing, which helps me see the potential in every home. Whether it’s preparing a property for sale or helping buyers envision how a house can become their home, I enjoy offering practical ideas that make a real difference.
Real estate is about more than transactions—it’s about relationships. As your neighbor, friend, and trusted advisor, I’m committed to guiding you through every step of the process with compassion, honesty, and expertise.
Whether you’re buying your first home, upgrading, downsizing, or looking to invest in Wisconsin real estate, I’m here to make the experience as smooth and enjoyable as possible. I look forward to being part of your real estate journey!
Client Reviews
It’s hard to fully capture the level of commitment Sarah brings to her work. She goes above and beyond, taking every result to heart as though it affects her personally. Caring, responsible, and always responsive, she sets a standard that’s rare to find. I would highly recommend her and look forward to working with her again.
Sarah was extremely helpful in providing info and details that made our property more marketable to prospective buyers. She also rolled up her sleeves and helped us put the presale finishing touches on the property. When communicating with Sarah, she was very prompt with replies and answers to any questions we had. We would use the phrase "immediate" to describe her response time! We were never waiting for her to reply. We will definitely use her in any future relestate transactions. She was fantastic!
From the very beginning, Sarah was there every step of the way. We had a unique situation with two homes on one property and had no idea how easy or difficult it would be to sell. Sarah researched, reached out to mentors, and made sure we had the information we needed. She went above and beyond—helping paint, stage, clean, and prepare our home for sale. Her hard work paid off because our home sold in just SIX HOURS! We definitely weren’t prepared for it to happen that quickly! Sarah then worked relentlessly to help us find a new home. She answered countless questions, calmed our worries, and genuinely cared about finding the right place for us. Sarah was so much more than our realtor. She truly cared about us and our next chapter. We are incredibly grateful for everything she did and would recommend her without hesitation. If you want a realtor who will truly go above and beyond, Sarah is the one!
Sarah helped us navigate through the home buying process with ease. We would absolutely recommend her services to anyone looking to purchase a property.
Sarah May was absolutely wonderful to work with throughout my home-buying journey. I came into town for a single weekend focused on finding a duplex, and when those options weren't the right fit, Sarah immediately pivoted and helped me explore single-family homes. She accommodated my tight schedule without hesitation and worked tirelessly to help me find the perfect forever home. What truly sets Sarah apart is how much she genuinely cares about her clients. Even after I returned out of town, she went above and beyond by touching up paint for the appraisal, coordinating with the lender and title company, answering countless questions, and even helping me choose paint colors. Having purchased homes before, I can confidently say Sarah is one of the best realtors I've ever worked with. She made a stressful process feel manageable and exciting, and I couldn't be more grateful for her dedication, professionalism, and friendship.
